RatingAdda
RatingAdda
Ratings with the receipts
Home / Protein Powder

Protein Powder

Based on real Reddit community discussions. Last updated 2 months ago. Each pick links back to the exact comments behind it - with sentiment highlighted clause by clause.

1,335
mentions
476
discussions
972
users

Top picks

25 of 58 ranked
1
Optimum Nutrition

Gold Standard 100% Whey

ON Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey gold standard whey on gold standard optimum optimum nutrition gold standard +1 more
94%
positive of 114 users
335 mentions
• Positive 33% (111) • Neutral 64% (216) • Negative 3% (8)
What people loved from upvoted comments
Common complaints from upvoted comments
  • “… [truncated] … is that the og Gold Standard one tastes a little too sweet for my liking. Moreover i have it with water everyday and it turns into this weird jelly like consistency probably cause of the Xanthan gum in it and i lowkey dont fuck with that. 🥀 Im on a protein powder taste testing spree. Pls drop your best tasting… [truncated] …”
  • “I also use Ascent from Costco, vanilla flavor. It was $10 off this last weekend, usually $50 for 4 lbs. Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard has some garbage ingredients btw. The best protein is Transparent Labs but it’s more expensive for less protein.”
Also discussed: Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Isolate ×3 Myprotein Impact Whey Protein ×1 Amul Pro Whey Protein ×1
2
The Whole Truth

Whey Protein Isolate+Concentrate

TWT The Whole Truth Whey Protein Isolate+Concentrate the whole truth foods twt protein whole truth
83%
positive of 58 users
200 mentions
• Positive 27% (54) • Neutral 68% (135) • Negative 5% (11)
Also discussed: Myprotein Impact Whey Protein ×1
3
Dymatize

ISO100

Dymatize ISO100 dymatize iso100 iso 100
95%
positive of 40 users
94 mentions
• Positive 43% (40) • Neutral 54% (51) • Negative 3% (3)
What people loved from upvoted comments
Also discussed: Myprotein Impact Whey Protein ×2 The Whole Truth Whey Protein Isolate+Concentrate ×1 Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey ×1
4
Isopure

Zero Carb

Isopure Zero Carb nature's best isopure
96%
positive of 23 users
43 mentions
• Positive 53% (23) • Neutral 44% (19) • Negative 3% (1)
What people loved from upvoted comments
  • “not sure we are allowed to post links but I get this one from Amazon and I really like it and don't taste it at all... Isopure Zero Carb 100% Pure Whey Isolate Protein Powder, Lactose Free, Gluten Free, with Vitamins, Unflavored, 25g Protein Per Serving”
  • “I bought the unflavoured one so I’m not the best one to advise on the taste but taste wise my favourite is isopure. It’s so smooth and good, I have tried other proteins too but nothing beats… [truncated] …”
  • Try isopure, taste is amazing, using cookies and cream rn
  • “IsoPure! Hands down! Zero whey protein taste bc it is not whey protein Literally tastes like a vanilla milkshake just using water Slightly more privy for elite macros 25/0/0 I just use Fairlife pre-packaged shakes though. Elite macros as well 150c 30g pro and they’re like $1.20 a pop buying in bulk
Also discussed: Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey ×2 Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Isolate ×2 Myprotein Impact Whey Protein ×1
5
Nakpro

Plant Protein

Nakpro Plant Protein nakpro gold nakpro perform nakpro platinum
76%
positive of 37 users
125 mentions
• Positive 26% (32) • Neutral 66% (82) • Negative 8% (11)
What people loved from upvoted comments
Common complaints from upvoted comments
6
MyProtein

Impact Whey Protein

MP Myprotein Impact Whey Protein my protein myprotein clear whey myprotein impact
76%
positive of 33 users
97 mentions
• Positive 26% (25) • Neutral 66% (64) • Negative 8% (8)
What people loved from upvoted comments
Also discussed: Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey ×1 Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Isolate ×1 MuscleBlaze Biozyme Performance Whey ×1
7
Amul

Pro Whey Protein

Amul Pro Whey Protein amul pro amul protein amul whey
77%
positive of 31 users
79 mentions
• Positive 32% (25) • Neutral 59% (47) • Negative 9% (7)
What people loved from upvoted comments
Common complaints from upvoted comments
  • “… [truncated] … TWT these whey brands are mostly on discount and never ever had this issue. This time I wanted to try amul and it is shit. Only with ASITIS and Amul.”
  • “… [truncated] … you can’t rely on it as a primary source and secondly that it’s too sweet. Amul whey products are more than a year old and they use whey (previously thrown away) produced as a byproduct during the manufacturing of their other dairy products - it can’t get any more settled than that.”
Also discussed: Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey ×1 Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Isolate ×1
8
Ghost

Whey

Ghost Whey ghost lifestyle ghost nutrition ghost protein ghost whey
100%
positive of 12 users
33 mentions
• Positive 36% (12) • Neutral 64% (21) • Negative 0% (0)
What people loved from upvoted comments
  • “Ryse is pretty notorious for being overly sweet and artificial tbh. Ghost whey is a solid step up, way cleaner tasting. If you liked PEScience before, just try a different flavour from their range… [truncated] …”
  • “Hey there! If you're looking for something that tastes good and doesn't feel like you're drinking chalk, give Ghost Whey a shot. Their cereal milk flavor is like a trip down breakfast memory lane, and it mixes like a dream even in a shaker bottle. Plus, it's not full of weird stuff - just solid, tasty gains! 🍦💪”
  • “I love the Optimum Nutrition Extreme Milk Chocolate. Ghost Whey Chocolate is good too. They taste close to shakes, mix well in shakers, and are smooth.”
Also discussed: Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey ×2 Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Isolate ×2 Ghost Vegan Protein ×2
9
Nutricost

Whey Protein Isolate

Nutricost Whey Protein Isolate nutricost protein nutricost whey
100%
positive of 12 users
32 mentions
• Positive 41% (13) • Neutral 59% (19) • Negative 0% (0)
Also discussed: Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey ×1 Myprotein Impact Whey Protein ×1 Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Isolate ×1
10
Transparent Labs

Grass-Fed Whey Protein Isolate

Transparent Labs Grass-Fed Whey Protein Isolate transparent labs grass fed transparent labs whey isolate
88%
positive of 17 users
30 mentions
• Positive 53% (16) • Neutral 40% (12) • Negative 7% (2)
Also discussed: Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey ×1 Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Isolate ×1
11
MuscleBlaze

Biozyme Performance Whey

MB MuscleBlaze Biozyme Performance Whey muscle blaze muscleblaze india
69%
positive of 29 users
138 mentions
• Positive 14% (20) • Neutral 78% (108) • Negative 8% (10)
What people loved from upvoted comments
  • I find Muscle blaze to be pretty reliable and comparatively affordable. They had a sale last week during which you can get 2kg whey protein for 5k.”
  • “… [truncated] … that MB is being made. So I’m assuming quality standards must be similar. I have been consuming MB now for a while and have happy with the consistency, have tried multiple wheys in the price range and mb biozyme gave me least stomach issues and tasted great
Also discussed: The Whole Truth Whey Protein Isolate+Concentrate ×1 Food Pharmer Only What's Needed Whey Protein ×1
12
Ascent

Whey Protein

Ascent Whey Protein ascent native fuel ascent whey
100%
positive of 7 users
10 mentions
• Positive 70% (7) • Neutral 30% (3) • Negative 0% (0)
What people loved from upvoted comments
  • I really like the vanilla Ascent whey protein from Costco. I make protein shakes with it and add fruit and other stuff. I have used it in different foods and also use it in my Creami for ice creams.  It’s pretty good and doesn’t have a weird aftertaste or anything.”
Also discussed: Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey ×1 Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Isolate ×1
13
BSN

Syntha-6

BSN Syntha-6 bsn syntha-6 syntha 6 syntha-6
91%
positive of 11 users
18 mentions
• Positive 56% (10) • Neutral 39% (7) • Negative 5% (1)
What people loved from upvoted comments
  • As far as taste goes, even my 12 yo enjoys the Syntha 6. We have the chocolate milkshake flavor. Works with water but better with milk I occasionally all yogurt, coffee, or tea to it as well.”
  • “… [truncated] … found they give me a stomach ache. No matter which particular product. Years ago I used to swear by BSN Syntha 6, which was always the best tasting in my opinion but haven't had it in a while.”
  • “BSN Syntha 6 Was basically a treat after every workout
  • “I think that chalky taste comes from all the artificial sweeteners and stuff. If it is available for you, you can try BSN Syntha-6 protein powder. BSN is owned by the same people who own ISOpure and ON so they seem pretty… [truncated] …”
Common complaints from upvoted comments
  • “Syntha 6 chocolate is by far the best I have ever tried. The protein works vanilla mixes really nicely with yoghurt. Otherwise majority of powders i have tried taste shit. Special shout out to myprotein vegan chocolate, absolute ass”
Also discussed: Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey ×1 Dymatize ISO100 ×1 Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Isolate ×1
14
Optimum Nutrition

Gold Standard 100% Isolate

ON Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Isolate gold standard whey on gold standard optimum optimum nutrition gold standard +1 more
100%
positive of 6 users
20 mentions
• Positive 30% (6) • Neutral 70% (14) • Negative 0% (0)
Also discussed: Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey ×3 The Whole Truth Whey Protein Isolate+Concentrate ×1
15
Food Pharmer

Only What's Needed Whey Protein

Food Pharmer Only What's Needed Whey Protein OWN food pharmer food pharmer own only what's needed only whats needed +2 more
100%
positive of 5 users
48 mentions
• Positive 10% (5) • Neutral 90% (43) • Negative 0% (0)
What people loved from upvoted comments
Also discussed: The Whole Truth Whey Protein Isolate+Concentrate ×1 MuscleBlaze Biozyme Performance Whey ×1
16
Vega

Sport Premium Protein

Vega Sport Premium Protein vega one vega protein vega sport
100%
positive of 4 users
13 mentions
• Positive 31% (4) • Neutral 69% (9) • Negative 0% (0)
Also discussed: Naked Nutrition Whey Protein ×1
17
Legion Athletics

Casein+

Legion Athletics Casein+ legion legion whey plus whey plus
100%
positive of 4 users
12 mentions
• Positive 33% (4) • Neutral 67% (8) • Negative 0% (0)
Also discussed: Myprotein Impact Whey Protein ×1
18
Ghost

Vegan Protein

Ghost Vegan Protein ghost lifestyle ghost nutrition ghost protein ghost whey
100%
positive of 4 users
10 mentions
• Positive 40% (4) • Neutral 60% (6) • Negative 0% (0)
What people loved from upvoted comments
Also discussed: Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey ×1 Ghost Whey ×1 Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Isolate ×1
19
Momentous

Whey Protein Isolate

Momentous Whey Protein Isolate momentous protein momentous whey
100%
positive of 4 users
6 mentions
• Positive 67% (4) • Neutral 33% (2) • Negative 0% (0)
Also discussed: Naked Nutrition Whey Protein ×2 Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey ×1 Dymatize ISO100 ×1
20
MuscleBlaze

Raw Whey Protein Isolate

MB MuscleBlaze Raw Whey Protein Isolate muscle blaze muscleblaze india
9 mentions
• Positive 33% (3) • Neutral 67% (6) • Negative 0% (0)
What people loved from upvoted comments
  • “I am shifting from MB 80% raw whey (somehow survived unflavoured). Now need a good tasting protein under budget (2400 the lower the better). What are the best tasting whey y'all have tasted and genuinely look forward to having instead of gulping down and praying to god.”
Also discussed: The Whole Truth Whey Protein Isolate+Concentrate ×1
21
Avvatar

IsoRich Whey Protein

Avvatar IsoRich Whey Protein avvatar absolute avvatar alpha
6 mentions
• Positive 50% (3) • Neutral 50% (3) • Negative 0% (0)
Also discussed: Food Pharmer Only What's Needed Whey Protein ×1
22
Naked Nutrition

Whey Protein

Naked Nutrition Whey Protein naked naked vegan naked vegan mass gainer naked whey naked whey protein isolate
88%
positive of 8 users
25 mentions
• Positive 28% (7) • Neutral 68% (17) • Negative 4% (1)
What people loved from upvoted comments
23
Yogabar

ProClean Plant Protein

Yogabar ProClean Plant Protein proclean whey yoga bar yogabar proclean
82%
positive of 11 users
21 mentions
• Positive 48% (10) • Neutral 43% (9) • Negative 9% (2)
What people loved from upvoted comments
  • “I take protein two times a day: plant protein in the morning to complete my meal’s protein content, and whey in the evening post-workout because whey is absorbed faster and has higher bioavailability. I use Yoga Bar plant protein, and it is quite good and really affordable
Common complaints from upvoted comments
Also discussed: Myprotein Impact Whey Protein ×1
24
Garden of Life

Raw Organic Protein

Garden Of Life Raw Organic Protein garden of life sport raw organic protein
5 mentions
• Positive 40% (2) • Neutral 60% (3) • Negative 0% (0)
25
Rule 1

R1 Protein

Limited Reddit discussion
R1 Rule 1 R1 Protein r1 protein rule 1 rule one
2 mentions
• Positive 100% (2) • Neutral 0% (0) • Negative 0% (0)